- Thread starter cheapmoa
- Start date

Nosler updated the BCs on the ablr, they are looking more realistic now:

https://www.nosler.com/accubond-long-range-bullet/

Well that changes things. I think most rifles these days are better than moa.

If you on your rifle are a .5 MOA shooting system @ 1200 yards with perfectly still conditions and perfect range estimation which is roughly 6" groups (that is very unlikely) then it only increases your Hit % at an equal amount for each simulation. Think about how difficult it is to hit a target on the 1st shot at 1200 yards. What do you think the average 1st Shot Hit % is at 1200 yards for most long range shooters?

Sorry if some of that is close to what you’ve done previously but I think it would be neat to see the incremental improvement in hit % as velocity is increased and everything else is held constant.

I have been working on a matrix to demonstrate where we can look at the effect of velocity on our HIT%. +/- 3% but this should give you some real insight.

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 6.42 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2600 - 13%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2700 - 14%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2800 - 18%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2900 - 20%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3000 - 23%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3100 - 26%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3200 - 30%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3300 - 33% - Recoil Energy of 8.64 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 8.33 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2600 - 12%

6 - 115 VLD - 2700 - 14%

6 - 115 VLD - 2800 - 16%

6 - 115 VLD - 2900 - 18%

6 - 115 VLD - 3000 - 22%

6 - 115 VLD - 3100 - 26%

6 - 115 VLD - 3200 - 30%

6 - 115 VLD - 3300 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 11.59 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2500 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 11.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2600 - 20%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2700 - 23%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2800 - 27%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2900 - 31%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3000 - 35%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3100 - 38%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3200 - 43%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3300 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 15.99 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 14.45 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31%

7 - 180 ELDM - 2700 - 34%

7 - 180 ELDM - 2800 - 38%

7 - 180 ELDM - 2900 - 43%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3000 - 47%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3100 - 52%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3200 - 56%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3300 - 59% - Recoil Energy of 21.27 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 6.42 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2600 - 13%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2700 - 14%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2800 - 18%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2900 - 20%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3000 - 23%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3100 - 26%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3200 - 30%

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3300 - 33% - Recoil Energy of 8.64 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 8.33 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2600 - 12%

6 - 115 VLD - 2700 - 14%

6 - 115 VLD - 2800 - 16%

6 - 115 VLD - 2900 - 18%

6 - 115 VLD - 3000 - 22%

6 - 115 VLD - 3100 - 26%

6 - 115 VLD - 3200 - 30%

6 - 115 VLD - 3300 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 11.59 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2500 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 11.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2600 - 20%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2700 - 23%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2800 - 27%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2900 - 31%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3000 - 35%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3100 - 38%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3200 - 43%

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3300 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 15.99 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 14.45 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31%

7 - 180 ELDM - 2700 - 34%

7 - 180 ELDM - 2800 - 38%

7 - 180 ELDM - 2900 - 43%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3000 - 47%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3100 - 52%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3200 - 56%

7 - 180 ELDM - 3300 - 59% - Recoil Energy of 21.27 (ft.lbf)

Last edited:

Likes:
LastShot300

I have been working on a matrix to demonstrate where we can look at the effect of velocity on our HIT% and the corresponding RECOIL. +/- 3% but this should give you some real insight. The 90 VLD look very appealing for PRS style matches in a 22 Creedmoor or 22 Nosler for a gas gun and for the best of all worlds the 7mm because at low velocity it beats everything in Hit % with a manageable recoil and at high velocity it is a long range hammer.

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 6.42 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2600 - 13% - Recoil Energy of 6.70 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 6.98 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2800 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 7.26 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2900 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 7.54 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3000 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 7.82 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 8.10 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 8.38 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3300 - 33% - Recoil Energy of 8.64 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 8.33 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2600 - 12% - Recoil Energy of 8.74 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 9.15 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2800 - 16% - Recoil Energy of 9.56 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2900 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 9.97 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3000 - 22% - Recoil Energy of 10.38 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 10.79 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 11.20 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3300 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 11.59 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2500 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 11.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2600 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 11.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2700 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 12.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2800 - 27% - Recoil Energy of 12.93 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2900 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 13.53 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3000 - 35% - Recoil Energy of 14.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3100 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 14.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3200 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 15.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3300 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 15.99 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 14.45 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 15.30 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2700 - 34% - Recoil Energy of 16.15 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2800 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 17.00 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2900 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 17.85 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3000 - 47% - Recoil Energy of 18.70 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3100 - 52% - Recoil Energy of 19.55 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3200 - 56% - Recoil Energy of 20.40 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3300 - 61% - Recoil Energy of 21.52 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2500 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 20.94 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2600 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 23.74 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2700 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 26.91 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2800 - 37% - Recoil Energy of 29.68 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2900 - 42% - Recoil Energy of 32.57 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3000 - 44% - Recoil Energy of 35.81 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3100 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 38.97 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3200 - 55% - Recoil Energy of 41.58 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3300 - 59% - Recoil Energy of 45.10 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 42.86 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2600 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 45.16 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2700 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 47.46 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2800 - 37% - Recoil Energy of 49.76 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2900 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 52.06 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3000 - 48% - Recoil Energy of 54.36 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3100 - 52% - Recoil Energy of 56.66 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3200 - 57% - Recoil Energy of 58.96 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3300 - 65% - Recoil Energy of 61.26 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 6.42 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2600 - 13% - Recoil Energy of 6.70 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 6.98 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2800 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 7.26 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2900 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 7.54 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3000 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 7.82 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 8.10 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 8.38 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3300 - 33% - Recoil Energy of 8.64 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 8.33 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2600 - 12% - Recoil Energy of 8.74 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 9.15 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2800 - 16% - Recoil Energy of 9.56 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2900 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 9.97 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3000 - 22% - Recoil Energy of 10.38 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 10.79 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 11.20 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3300 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 11.59 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2500 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 11.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2600 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 11.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2700 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 12.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2800 - 27% - Recoil Energy of 12.93 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2900 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 13.53 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3000 - 35% - Recoil Energy of 14.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3100 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 14.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3200 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 15.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3300 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 15.99 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 14.45 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 15.30 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2700 - 34% - Recoil Energy of 16.15 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2800 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 17.00 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2900 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 17.85 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3000 - 47% - Recoil Energy of 18.70 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3100 - 52% - Recoil Energy of 19.55 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3200 - 56% - Recoil Energy of 20.40 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3300 - 61% - Recoil Energy of 21.52 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2500 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 20.94 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2600 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 23.74 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2700 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 26.91 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2800 - 37% - Recoil Energy of 29.68 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 2900 - 42% - Recoil Energy of 32.57 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3000 - 44% - Recoil Energy of 35.81 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3100 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 38.97 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3200 - 55% - Recoil Energy of 41.58 (ft.lbf)

7.62 - 225 ELDM - 3300 - 59% - Recoil Energy of 45.10 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 42.86 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2600 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 45.16 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2700 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 47.46 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2800 - 37% - Recoil Energy of 49.76 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 2900 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 52.06 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3000 - 48% - Recoil Energy of 54.36 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3100 - 52% - Recoil Energy of 56.66 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3200 - 57% - Recoil Energy of 58.96 (ft.lbf)

338 - 285 ELDM - 3300 - 65% - Recoil Energy of 61.26 (ft.lbf)

Last edited:

I'm placing an order for a rifle this week and I'm between a 6.5 SAUM and 7 SAUM.

I'd run 147 elm and 150 smk in the 6.5, and 183 and 197 smk in the 7. Parameters - wind call error of 5mph, standard deviation of 4, and target range error of 3 yds.

What velocity and BC? The assumptions don't matter in the comparison as long as they are the same for all the bullets fired in the simulation. What distance are you wanting to shoot out to. The 7mm is going to be a 20% or more increase in Hit% over a 6.5 at 1200+

Likes:
LastShot300

If I stated that right then at 1200 yard ( I am actually shooting 1250 because that is the set distance at the range I am a member of ) that using a .243 with a velocity of 2992 shooting the Hornady BTHP match 105's my hit rate is on a 12.5" target is on average, 21% out of 1000 shots right?

If I stated that right then at 1200 yard ( I am actually shooting 1250 because that is the set distance at the range I am a member of ) that using a .243 with a velocity of 2992 shooting the Hornady BTHP match 105's my hit rate is on a 12.5" target is on average, 21% out of 1000 shots right?

We can't calculate after the 1st Shot because you should technically get more and more accurate after you get a read from your previous shots by correcting for wind, range and shooter error. That is why so many shooters use sighters and walk it on and then shoot a group. That is not a true test of their system capability.

What would you say your 1st Shot hit percentage is at 1250? If it is hgher than 21% then that means you are better than the set assumptions with your rifle system which would directly translate to another system. For example if you are currently shooting your 243 WIN -105 - 2992 then everything above 21% on that chart is going to increase your HIT% accordingly.

The recoil is listed so that you can make a decision based on the end use of the rifle. Most PRS shooters want as low of recoil as possible so they can always get a read and stay on target from awkward firing positions. That is why the 22 Nosler in a gas gun or a bolt in 22 Creedmoor looks so appealing with the 90 VLDs at 3000 - 3200. If rapid follow up shots are not as important or you can manage recoil well then the 7mm is the hands down best choice because it is so flexible and has the highest BC by a large margin. If you plan on shooting past 1200 yards then the 7mm really pulls away.

I have been working on a matrix to demonstrate where we can look at the effect of velocity on our HIT% and the corresponding RECOIL. +/- 3% but this should give you some real insight. The 90 VLD look very appealing for PRS style matches in a 22 Creedmoor or 22 Nosler for a gas gun and for the best of all worlds the 7mm because at low velocity it beats everything in Hit % with a managable recoil and at high velocity it is a long range hammer.

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 6.42 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2600 - 13% - Recoil Energy of 6.70 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 6.98 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2800 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 7.26 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2900 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 7.54 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3000 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 7.82 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 8.10 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 8.38 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3300 - 33% - Recoil Energy of 8.64 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 8.33 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2600 - 12% - Recoil Energy of 8.74 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 9.15 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2800 - 16% - Recoil Energy of 9.56 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2900 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 9.97 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3000 - 22% - Recoil Energy of 10.38 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 10.79 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 11.20 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3300 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 11.59 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2500 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 11.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2600 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 11.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2700 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 12.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2800 - 27% - Recoil Energy of 12.93 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2900 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 13.53 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3000 - 35% - Recoil Energy of 14.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3100 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 14.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3200 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 15.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3300 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 15.99 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 14.45 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 15.30 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2700 - 34% - Recoil Energy of 16.15 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2800 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 17.00 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2900 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 17.85 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3000 - 47% - Recoil Energy of 18.70 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3100 - 52% - Recoil Energy of 19.55 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3200 - 56% - Recoil Energy of 20.40 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3300 - 59% - Recoil Energy of 21.27 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 6.42 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2600 - 13% - Recoil Energy of 6.70 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 6.98 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2800 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 7.26 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 2900 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 7.54 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3000 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 7.82 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 8.10 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 8.38 (ft.lbf)

5.56 - 90 VLD - 3300 - 33% - Recoil Energy of 8.64 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2500 - 11% - Recoil Energy of 8.33 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2600 - 12% - Recoil Energy of 8.74 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2700 - 14% - Recoil Energy of 9.15 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2800 - 16% - Recoil Energy of 9.56 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 2900 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 9.97 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3000 - 22% - Recoil Energy of 10.38 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3100 - 26% - Recoil Energy of 10.79 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3200 - 30% - Recoil Energy of 11.20 (ft.lbf)

6 - 115 VLD - 3300 - 32% - Recoil Energy of 11.59 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2500 - 18% - Recoil Energy of 11.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2600 - 20% - Recoil Energy of 11.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2700 - 23% - Recoil Energy of 12.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2800 - 27% - Recoil Energy of 12.93 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 2900 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 13.53 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3000 - 35% - Recoil Energy of 14.13 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3100 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 14.73 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3200 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 15.33 (ft.lbf)

6.5 - 147 ELDM - 3300 - 49% - Recoil Energy of 15.99 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2500 - 28% - Recoil Energy of 14.45 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31% - Recoil Energy of 15.30 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2700 - 34% - Recoil Energy of 16.15 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2800 - 38% - Recoil Energy of 17.00 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 2900 - 43% - Recoil Energy of 17.85 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3000 - 47% - Recoil Energy of 18.70 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3100 - 52% - Recoil Energy of 19.55 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3200 - 56% - Recoil Energy of 20.40 (ft.lbf)

7 - 180 ELDM - 3300 - 59% - Recoil Energy of 21.27 (ft.lbf)

And not to take away from this or hurt feelings but I'd like to point out some things just to inform so people can consider them.

The first thing is barrel life, cranking speeds the highest with long baring surface bullets is going to substantially decrease barrel life. Here in the Beyond 1000 forum just a few days ago a guy was commenting on extremely low barrel life, 300-400 rounds, with huge 7mm's. It won't be too un-similar with other calibers.

Next is bullet failure at higher speeds, chasing the higher velocities, I've had this happen with different chamberings, so no free lunch so to speak. Sometimes the bullet you picked doesn't work in your barrel whereas another one will.

There really is a performance balance when "all things considered" come into play.

Likes:
longshooter and SilentStalkr

Definitely. The system has to work but with cabon fiber barrels and melonite coatings the barrel life numbers are only going to get better. 90 VLDs are proven performers at 3000 - 3200 from 1:7 twist melonite barrels good for 2000+

7mm-08 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31% Hit with 1:7.5 Twist Barrel

In my opinion, this is the most balanced system for all around use. It beats the 6.5 CM across the board and has great barrel life. 3000+ and double that with Melonite.

7mm-08 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31% Hit with 1:7.5 Twist Barrel

In my opinion, this is the most balanced system for all around use. It beats the 6.5 CM across the board and has great barrel life. 3000+ and double that with Melonite.

Last edited:

7mm-08 - 180 ELDM - 2600 - 31% Hit with 1:7.5 Twist Barrel

In my opinion, this is the most balanced system for all around use. It beats the 6.5 CM across the board and has great barrel life. 3000+ and double that with Melonite.

Likes:
cheapmoa

I'd still lean towards a 6.5 Creedmoor personally as in all-around I'd consider prs stuff. A 180 gr out of 7-08 will be like shooting a 308 in terms of recoil which is fine but hardly ideal for match use.

For PRS where most targets are under 900 yards and energy doesn't matter then I wonder if the 22 Cal. might get some action. If you could get the same HIT% @ half the recoil and get 2000+ rounds out of the barrel is that a good setup for PRS?

I appreciate your thoughts on this thread.

Last edited:

https://underwoodammo.com/product/rifle-ammo/300-aac-blackout-111-grain-match-solid-flash-tip/

Unless they have setup a more advanced way of checking hits & misses, as you might hit the target but not get noticed.

Going down the path of assumptions and connecting the dots back to PRS shooting, I'd refine a couple things in the model.

I would assume rifle precision of 1/2 MOA and SD of something more like 6-7. That would be average for the PRS shooters I know. Some guys I know wouldn't even be happy with those numbers.

Vertical dispersion is usually very good for most shooters. I've got targets at 950 and 1225 yards and can say that essentially all of my misses are left/right due to wind and not due to vertical. A common competition cartridge like the 6 Dasher has no problem printing a 1/2 MOA or better waterline out at 1200 yards. At 1000 yards it's common for guys to be getting 3-4" vertical. So realistically the vast majority of misses in competition are due to shooter error (positional instability) or wind error.

The other bigger picture comment I would offer is that PRS shooting is fundamentally a feedback loop system. The key thing is the ability to see downrange hits and make corrections on the fly. While your model is assuming 2mph initial wind call error, that data could just as easily be tranferred to a 2mph change in wind that the shooter did not notice while they were shooting the stage - a very common thing. The feedback loop has two key components, lack of recoil to allow shooter to stay on target, and downrange energy to produce a result that's actually observable. Going too far down the light/fast small caliber bullet path can make it harder to see misses, especially on things like wet dirt or grass. And chasing a bit of ballistics at the cost of recoil can also be problematic. If you have one or two shots where you don't see where your miss was because of recoil, or also where you don't see where your HIT was (left/right/center of plate), you lose the ability to make a correction that can greatly outweigh a theoretical ballistic advantage.

Last thought would be totally unrelated to ballistics, just practical consideration on cartridge reliability. Shooters want a cartridge that is going to be predictable and stable over the course of barrel life. Last thing you want in a match is barrel slowing down or groups opening up due to throat erosion. It's this that I've seen bring some shooters back to cartridges like 6.5x47. It may not be the lightest recoiling, but it's very accurate and very predictable over the course of its barrel life. That same factor likely keeps guys away from things like 22 creedmoor or 22-250 which are a bit overbore with less barrel life.

I would assume rifle precision of 1/2 MOA and SD of something more like 6-7. That would be average for the PRS shooters I know. Some guys I know wouldn't even be happy with those numbers.

Vertical dispersion is usually very good for most shooters. I've got targets at 950 and 1225 yards and can say that essentially all of my misses are left/right due to wind and not due to vertical. A common competition cartridge like the 6 Dasher has no problem printing a 1/2 MOA or better waterline out at 1200 yards. At 1000 yards it's common for guys to be getting 3-4" vertical. So realistically the vast majority of misses in competition are due to shooter error (positional instability) or wind error.

The other bigger picture comment I would offer is that PRS shooting is fundamentally a feedback loop system. The key thing is the ability to see downrange hits and make corrections on the fly. While your model is assuming 2mph initial wind call error, that data could just as easily be tranferred to a 2mph change in wind that the shooter did not notice while they were shooting the stage - a very common thing. The feedback loop has two key components, lack of recoil to allow shooter to stay on target, and downrange energy to produce a result that's actually observable. Going too far down the light/fast small caliber bullet path can make it harder to see misses, especially on things like wet dirt or grass. And chasing a bit of ballistics at the cost of recoil can also be problematic. If you have one or two shots where you don't see where your miss was because of recoil, or also where you don't see where your HIT was (left/right/center of plate), you lose the ability to make a correction that can greatly outweigh a theoretical ballistic advantage.

Last thought would be totally unrelated to ballistics, just practical consideration on cartridge reliability. Shooters want a cartridge that is going to be predictable and stable over the course of barrel life. Last thing you want in a match is barrel slowing down or groups opening up due to throat erosion. It's this that I've seen bring some shooters back to cartridges like 6.5x47. It may not be the lightest recoiling, but it's very accurate and very predictable over the course of its barrel life. That same factor likely keeps guys away from things like 22 creedmoor or 22-250 which are a bit overbore with less barrel life.

Likes:
BLKWLFK9 and cheapmoa

I would assume rifle precision of 1/2 MOA and SD of something more like 6-7. That would be average for the PRS shooters I know. Some guys I know wouldn't even be happy with those numbers.

Vertical dispersion is usually very good for most shooters. I've got targets at 950 and 1225 yards and can say that essentially all of my misses are left/right due to wind and not due to vertical. A common competition cartridge like the 6 Dasher has no problem printing a 1/2 MOA or better waterline out at 1200 yards. At 1000 yards it's common for guys to be getting 3-4" vertical. So realistically the vast majority of misses in competition are due to shooter error (positional instability) or wind error.

The other bigger picture comment I would offer is that PRS shooting is fundamentally a feedback loop system. The key thing is the ability to see downrange hits and make corrections on the fly. While your model is assuming 2mph initial wind call error, that data could just as easily be tranferred to a 2mph change in wind that the shooter did not notice while they were shooting the stage - a very common thing. The feedback loop has two key components, lack of recoil to allow shooter to stay on target, and downrange energy to produce a result that's actually observable. Going too far down the light/fast small caliber bullet path can make it harder to see misses, especially on things like wet dirt or grass. And chasing a bit of ballistics at the cost of recoil can also be problematic. If you have one or two shots where you don't see where your miss was because of recoil, or also where you don't see where your HIT was (left/right/center of plate), you lose the ability to make a correction that can greatly outweigh a theoretical ballistic advantage.

Last thought would be totally unrelated to ballistics, just practical consideration on cartridge reliability. Shooters want a cartridge that is going to be predictable and stable over the course of barrel life. Last thing you want in a match is barrel slowing down or groups opening up due to throat erosion. It's this that I've seen bring some shooters back to cartridges like 6.5x47. It may not be the lightest recoiling, but it's very accurate and very predictable over the course of its barrel life. That same factor likely keeps guys away from things like 22 creedmoor or 22-250 which are a bit overbore with less barrel life.

I agree with everything you stated above. Doesn't that seem to support a 7-08 shooting a 180 ELDM at 2500-600? That would increase HIT% by 10-15% over the 6.5CM and give you better energy on target to see splash and impacts and it costs you less than a pound of RECOIL.

A slow bullet also introduces difficulties such as being more susceptible to ranging errors, more susceptible to rifle cant errors by the shooter, hitting transonic a bit sooner, and having more vertical dispersion as a result of SD at the outer edge of the performance envelope.

Guys I know that are chasing ballistics tend to be shooting things like a 6.5 Addiction with a 140gr bullet at 3050ish, or 6 Creed with a 110 or 115 at 3100. Those are functionally as good as the 7mm 180 combo, with a lot better speed and both have less recoil.

A 7mm with a 180 at 2500-2600 is a LOT of recoil compared to a 6mm 105 at 2950 fps. Roughly double the recoil according to the little online calculator I played with. It does give you a bit of improvement on wind, miss your 1000 yard wind call by 2mph and you will be off target by 0.3mil with the 7mm and 0.4 mil with the 6mm. That might be an edge hit on a 2 MOA target. However, inside of 600 yards with all the positional shooting you'd be at a serious disadvantage.

A slow bullet also introduces difficulties such as being more susceptible to ranging errors, more susceptible to rifle cant errors by the shooter, hitting transonic a bit sooner, and having more vertical dispersion as a result of SD at the outer edge of the performance envelope.

Guys I know that are chasing ballistics tend to be shooting things like a 6.5 Addiction with a 140gr bullet at 3050ish, or 6 Creed with a 110 or 115 at 3100. Those are functionally as good as the 7mm 180 combo, with a lot better speed and both have less recoil.

A slow bullet also introduces difficulties such as being more susceptible to ranging errors, more susceptible to rifle cant errors by the shooter, hitting transonic a bit sooner, and having more vertical dispersion as a result of SD at the outer edge of the performance envelope.

Guys I know that are chasing ballistics tend to be shooting things like a 6.5 Addiction with a 140gr bullet at 3050ish, or 6 Creed with a 110 or 115 at 3100. Those are functionally as good as the 7mm 180 combo, with a lot better speed and both have less recoil.

So 6 is the perfect caliber for PRS type competition because it has lower recoil than the 6.5 and 7 but still is visible over the 22 Cal. and the shooting distances in PRS are just not far enough to justify the much higher BC bullet in 7?

most of the top guys wont even consider anything but 6mm if they are seriously there to compete...i dont think most shooters understand the difficulty of shooting/spotting/correcting all on your own sometimes in field conditions with no berms while under time constraints in non ideal positions you had to build in a few seconds

Likes:
BLKWLFK9

So 6 is the perfect caliber for PRS type competition because it has lower recoil than the 6.5 and 7 but still is visible over the 22 Cal. and the shooting distances in PRS are just not far enough to justify the much higher BC bullet in 7?

Likes:
cheapmoa

You are talking about 6.5CM @ 13lbs vs 7-08 @ 14.5lbs for similar HIT% and after a muzzle brake or suppressor is added to each you are talking about less than 1 lbs. of difference in recoil. In my opinion the energy and long range BC upsides on the 7mm is worth the added pound of recoil.

For PRS where most targets are under 900 yards and energy doesn't matter then I wonder if the 22 Cal. might get some action. If you could get the same HIT% @ half the recoil and get 2000+ rounds out of the barrel is that a good setup for PRS?

I appreciate your thoughts on this thread.

For PRS where most targets are under 900 yards and energy doesn't matter then I wonder if the 22 Cal. might get some action. If you could get the same HIT% @ half the recoil and get 2000+ rounds out of the barrel is that a good setup for PRS?

I appreciate your thoughts on this thread.