Best available over-the-ear hearing protection and why?

Fred @ Bison Tactical

Bison Tactical
Commercial Supporter
Online Training Access
Belligerents
Minuteman
May 18, 2012
1,340
139
169
Boulder, CO
www.BisonTactical.com
Guys, I am looking to upgrade my hearing protection from the Howard Leight Impact muffs I currently use.

I want the best hearing protection that I can shoot precision rifle with.

They need to be over the ear and comfortable for multi-day use.

If you have suggestions about why they are the best, I would like that info.
I don't care too much about extra's like connection to phone, bluetooth etc, I just want them to save my hearing, and they need to be able to transmit sounds from RO's talking so I can hear what they say.

I do like long battery life...
 

Lonestar1027

LT
Belligerents
May 11, 2017
211
122
49
CA
I use Peltor Sport Tactical 500's and love them. I upgraded the cups to the gel versions and I can wear them all day, with glasses and not have an issue. They have a nice cutout for the stock and never get in the way for me. For solo days at the range, the bluetooth is nice so you can pair it with a phone and listen to music. Unlike the Howard Leights, the Peltors use sound compression instead of threshold clipping. By compressing loud noises over a certain dB rating, you can still have a completely normal conversation with gunshots going off in the background and not experience any cut outs or loss of clarity. Battery life is good and I would buy another set if they broke tonight.
 

phxfa

Gunny Sergeant
Belligerents
Mar 9, 2010
1,284
70
154
Arizona
MSA Sordin Supreme Pro-X’s get my vote. Tapered cup where it would interfere with the stock, less likely to break the seal. Gel cups, (optional) behind the head strap or over the head, great noise reduction with clear, adjustable volume control. I use non alkaline batteries, decent battery life with lithium’s.
 

Fred @ Bison Tactical

Bison Tactical
Commercial Supporter
Online Training Access
Belligerents
Minuteman
May 18, 2012
1,340
139
169
Boulder, CO
www.BisonTactical.com
I have been thinking about the MSA's, and I know a bunch of guys here have tried a LOT of different ear pro, so figured I would ask before spending the $$. I haven't hear a lot about the Peltor's has anyone used both and can do a objective comparison?
 

mkollman74

Quo Vadis?
Belligerents
Nov 5, 2009
1,235
51
154
WA, USA
MSA Sordin Supreme Pro-X’s get my vote. Tapered cup where it would interfere with the stock, less likely to break the seal. Gel cups, (optional) behind the head strap or over the head, great noise reduction with clear, adjustable volume control. I use non alkaline batteries, decent battery life with lithium’s.
^^THIS^^
 

Dirty8404

Sergeant of the Hide
Belligerents
Minuteman
Apr 17, 2018
199
149
49
I have the Sordins with gel cups and behind the head strap, they are nice. Haven’t tested them against Peltors, but I’d definitely get them again.
 

Nik H

Constantly Learning
Online Training Access
Belligerents
Jan 22, 2014
5,948
4,663
219
Rhode Island
Sordins are better than Peltors in every way....comfort, sound attenuation and reliability
 

SLG

Gunny Sergeant
Belligerents
Sep 2, 2009
828
334
69
I have been using Peltor Com tacs for the last 15 years. The Gen1's are far and way the best, but the latest (gen3, I think) are also quite good, and most people like the form factor better. I have tried Sordin's, Leight's, and some other Peltor models. I vastly prefer the ruggedness and fit of the Comtacs. I do prefer to replace the ear cups with gel cups, but its not 100% needed.

I have a set of the Safariland TCI's coming to try as well.

None of these, or any others mentioned here, give enough hearing protection on there own. I either use a can, or plugs, to augment them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gil P.

Threadcutter308

Outlier
Belligerents
Feb 13, 2017
5,421
8,065
119
Camano Island, Washington
No. Safariland TCI DEHP. These are more like $415.
These appear to be "Re-branded" MSA Sordins, which, if true, is OK. I have Sordins and really like them. I have the headband version. I think I paid in the area of $275.00 for them about 3 years ago. To do it over again, I would probably go with the version that can be worn under a helmet/ball cap.
 

Fred @ Bison Tactical

Bison Tactical
Commercial Supporter
Online Training Access
Belligerents
Minuteman
May 18, 2012
1,340
139
169
Boulder, CO
www.BisonTactical.com
Tbac ultra series
Yeah I use them on MY rifles, but not everyone is so civilized :).

Actually, I switched back to a brake for competition but am likely going to go back to competing suppressed next season, I just need to move my training back to suppressed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SilentStalkr

Mute

Sergeant
Belligerents
Sep 9, 2003
811
140
49
52
Diamond Bar, CA
www.amtraininggroup.com
These appear to be "Re-branded" MSA Sordins, which, if true, is OK. I have Sordins and really like them. I have the headband version. I think I paid in the area of $275.00 for them about 3 years ago. To do it over again, I would probably go with the version that can be worn under a helmet/ball cap.
I have Sordins. One of my friends have the Safariland. They don't appear to be re-branded. I tried them and they seem to do a slightly better job of blocking the loud noises while still allowing you to hear conversation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dan M

Threadcutter308

Outlier
Belligerents
Feb 13, 2017
5,421
8,065
119
Camano Island, Washington
I have Sordins. One of my friends have the Safariland. They don't appear to be re-branded. I tried them and they seem to do a slightly better job of blocking the loud noises while still allowing you to hear conversation.
Yeah, I only glanced at them quickly, but from what I saw, the headband internals and the mic covers appeared similar, if not the same. In any event, for the $$'s asked for either one, they should be pretty good. ("Should be" anyway.....).
 

dghboy315

Mid Atlantic Rimfire Series
Belligerents
I used MSA’s for years and they have worked great for me. Reliable even in all day wet conditons. Clear surround sound amplification. Good noise reduction although I need to use ear plugs at indooor ranges. Comfortable for all day wear but I would upgrade to gel cups. My only problems with them are that they can get hot in warm weather and they can sometime interfere with cheek weld. I’ve recently been trying out in-ear options. I’ve come to rally like Nacre QuietPro headset. I got a used mil-surplus set for $60 off eBay. Excellent noise amplification, almost as good as the MSAs. Very comfortable since they have different sized ear tips. The unit test the sound seal every time you power on the unit. For the price, they can’t be beat. And it is nice to wear something besides a baseball cap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spife7980

Dirty8404

Sergeant of the Hide
Belligerents
Minuteman
Apr 17, 2018
199
149
49
None of these, or any others mentioned here, give enough hearing protection on there own. I either use a can, or plugs, to augment them.
Have to agree with this, I shoot with a can and my Sordins do great but when a heathen with a brake is next to me, I know it.
 

LawnMM

Harbinger of Sarcasm
Belligerents
Jul 5, 2009
2,238
983
219
Colorado
MSA Sordins, Fred. Triad sells them with the gel cups, well worth it. Comfortable for all weekend matches. I get headaches a lot, including migraines, particularly when stuff is squeezing my head hours on end. None with these.

Battery life is stupid long, they auto shut off if you forget. I have had mine for a few years now, changed batteries once. The noise amplification is clear and directional.

They're outstanding, if mine died tomorrow I'd buy a new set without any hesitation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stpilot12 and TJC

Sogan

Sergeant
Belligerents
Jun 11, 2013
542
126
49
The MSA Sordins are a night and day difference in sound clarity and sound amplification compared to the Howard Leight Impact muffs. I own the Sordins and my buddy has the Howard Leights - I can hear animals in the brush well before he can when hunting. I tried his Howard Leights and voices sound muffled and not near as clear as the Sordins to me
 

Bradu

Full Member
Banned !
Belligerents
Aug 24, 2011
2,621
670
219
IL
You will like them. I don't own a set but have tried my buddy's and they are so comfortable and work well. Only reason I don't have them is they don't work well for me with the a desert techs because they hit the stock.
 

Bradu

Full Member
Banned !
Belligerents
Aug 24, 2011
2,621
670
219
IL
If I was getting some right now then I’d go for in ear. Even the Sordins interfere with stocks for me.
That's why I'm still using the throwaway yellow foam plugs. They offer more protection than anything I've tried but they suck because you have to pull them out to hear a conversation.
 

shoobe01

Private
Hessian
Belligerents
Feb 15, 2005
248
98
34
Mission, KS
www.donttouchme.com
Sordins, with gel earcups and a memory foam top pad. Which model? Do not care. I have a comms headsets I use for earpro so I don't have several to pick between, but they all work the same.

I have friends with Peltors, and have no issue if you go that way.

TEA and TCI used to (I THINK) simply upgrade Sordins with all new internals, but I believe now build only new. They are NOT rebranded Sordins but absolutely have different internals. Some also say they are more waterproof, but I have abused the hell out of my Sordins and never shorted or ruined them.

Keep spare batteries around. Use only lithium batteries.

Foam earplugs under the electronics help but are just a small extra bit of help, Not only do the earmuffs have better sound ratings, they provide more AREA of protection. Do not forget that your ears are in your head. Sounds like gunfire and explosions come through other parts of your head just fine. Larger earpro, integral goggles, even a helmet, help reduce sound to your eardrums also
 

Frog05

KeepItSimpleStupid
Belligerents
Feb 15, 2017
263
197
49
Southern Illinois
Good choice on the Sordins! I’ve ran them for about a year and love them. I still double up with earplugs if I am shooting indoors. The gel cups are super comfortable. My buddies run comtacs and love them but the Sordins just sound better to my ears and the controls are easier to manipulate for me, especially with gloves on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shoobe01

SilentStalkr

Wonna Be Badass
Belligerents
Oct 8, 2012
2,348
1,733
219
39
Somewhere in the US
I think the Sordins would be great if they reversed the ear piece 180 so that the battery compartment or whatever it is, while it is still narrow is not as narrow as the top part and therefore still gets in the way of a stock, imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fx77

Basher

I fly stuff and I know things.
Online Training Access
Belligerents
Dec 13, 2004
1,736
1,227
219
33
Chandler AZ, USA
I think the Sordins would be great if they reversed the ear piece 180 so that the battery compartment or whatever it is, while it is still narrow is not as narrow as the top part and therefore still gets in the way of a stock, imo.
On the Sordins? Looks like Sordins have a cutout on the bottom. Peltors have the battery hump on the bottom, which has always concerned me that they'd ruin my cheekweld. I'm trying to decide what to get as well. I'm hoping to find somewhere local that has both that I can try.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shoobe01

SilentStalkr

Wonna Be Badass
Belligerents
Oct 8, 2012
2,348
1,733
219
39
Somewhere in the US
On the Sordins? Looks like Sordins have a cutout on the bottom. Peltors have the battery hump on the bottom, which has always concerned me that they'd ruin my cheekweld. I'm trying to decide what to get as well. I'm hoping to find somewhere local that has both that I can try.
The older Sordins didn’t have cutouts on the bottom. While they were thin, they still had a hump for the battery compartment and microphone/electronic shit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Basher

Frog05

KeepItSimpleStupid
Belligerents
Feb 15, 2017
263
197
49
Southern Illinois
On the Sordins? Looks like Sordins have a cutout on the bottom. Peltors have the battery hump on the bottom, which has always concerned me that they'd ruin my cheekweld. I'm trying to decide what to get as well. I'm hoping to find somewhere local that has both that I can try.
The Sordins I have are cutout on the bottom which for me is a lot better than the Peltors which have the hump on the bottom.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Basher

Basher

I fly stuff and I know things.
Online Training Access
Belligerents
Dec 13, 2004
1,736
1,227
219
33
Chandler AZ, USA
The Sordins I have are cutout on the bottom which for me is a lot better than the Peltors which have the hump on the bottom.
Right, which has always been my concern. But I hear otherwise amazing reviews on the Peltors. I'm hoping to try both on before buying, if possible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frog05

RNWRKNP

Sophisticated Redneck
Belligerents
Minuteman
Dec 13, 2017
1,550
2,048
119
PHX, AZ
On the Sordins? Looks like Sordins have a cutout on the bottom. Peltors have the battery hump on the bottom, which has always concerned me that they'd ruin my cheekweld. I'm trying to decide what to get as well. I'm hoping to find somewhere local that has both that I can try.
In the same boat amigo. Here in town I’ve found the 100’s but not the 3-500’s. From what I’ve read, you’ll want the Tac 300’s at minimum. Lowlight gave the 500’s the thumbs up in a podcast if you don’t follow it. For me, the 4x amplification of the Sordins for hunting is very attractive. The Peltors are clear but do not amplify and lack the cut out at the bottom.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frog05

Baron85

Sergeant
Belligerents
Mar 18, 2012
372
70
34
34
I run sordins with gel cups. They are very comfortable but I don't find they provide enough sound reduction if I'm shooting around others with brakes. I double up with plugs and muffs. If I am shooting by myself or with people running suppressors they are perfect. Very comfortable and haven't had any issue interfering with my cheek weld.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frog05

Fred @ Bison Tactical

Bison Tactical
Commercial Supporter
Online Training Access
Belligerents
Minuteman
May 18, 2012
1,340
139
169
Boulder, CO
www.BisonTactical.com
I have tried running in-ear plugs for a while, but they were painful after 2 days of competition. I switched back to my muffs (Howard Leight) but wanted something that was more comfortable. I shot for a day with the Sordins, and so far they are very comfortable, have good hearing protection and seem to work well. I didn't have an issue with cheekweld. I will run them this coming weekend at the Quiet Riot in UT for a 2 day match and have more feedback after that.
 

SilentStalkr

Wonna Be Badass
Belligerents
Oct 8, 2012
2,348
1,733
219
39
Somewhere in the US
I have tried running in-ear plugs for a while, but they were painful after 2 days of competition. I switched back to my muffs (Howard Leight) but wanted something that was more comfortable. I shot for a day with the Sordins, and so far they are very comfortable, have good hearing protection and seem to work well. I didn't have an issue with cheekweld. I will run them this coming weekend at the Quiet Riot in UT for a 2 day match and have more feedback after that.
Guess I’m weird and my ears are closer to my jawline than most, I suppose.
 

FUNCTIONAL

Dirty Civilian
Belligerents
Feb 19, 2012
694
183
49
Charlotte, NC
Guess im going to be the odd man out and say I use Howard Leights with gel cups and a padded headband cover for $50 more and they have been excellent. Just under $100 total and they have been perfect when used for 3 days straight.

Still like everyone though inside shooting I prefer to throw in foamies with the HLs and just crank the volume.